2026-11-20 · 3 min read · Franklin
Why Does the Same Price House Cost More Each Month in One Town Than Another?

The short answer
Property taxes. Every city has its own tax rate, and for most buyers the tax is part of the monthly payment. Two homes with the same price can have payments that are nearly $300 a month apart.
I'm a Home Buying Realtor in Franklin, WI, and this post is part of my series on choosing where to live. Price is only the start. Today is the cost that comes after the price.
Where the rate comes from
Your tax bill is several taxes added together: the city, the county, the school district and the technical college. That total is different in every city.
The rates, city by city
The State of Wisconsin publishes an average rate for every city, measured against market value so cities can be compared fairly. Here are the 2025 rates, on bills paid in 2026, per $1,000 of value:
- New Berlin: $11.11
- Franklin: $14.86
- Greenfield: $17.21
- West Allis: $19.61
- Milwaukee (Milwaukee County part): $20.78
Source: Wisconsin Department of Revenue, 2025 Town, Village and City Taxes, effective full value rate. Read November 12, 2026.
What that means on a $350,000 home
- New Berlin: about $3,889 a year, or $324 a month
- Franklin: about $5,201 a year, or $433 a month
- Greenfield: about $6,024 a year, or $502 a month
- West Allis: about $6,864 a year, or $572 a month
- Milwaukee: about $7,273 a year, or $606 a month
That's a $282 a month difference between the highest and lowest, on the same price. In Franklin, the same $350,000 home runs about $433 a month in taxes.
Why your bill won't match exactly
These are averages for the whole city. Some cities have more than one school district, and the rate changes with the district. A real bill also depends on the home's assessed value and the state credits. One of those credits lowers the bill a little more on the home you live in. And taxes change every year.
So use the list to compare cities. Use the real bill to decide on a house. When you get pre-approved, your lender uses an estimate for taxes. Once you have a house in mind, give them the real number so the payment you're shown is close to the one you'll have.
How to find the real tax bill on any home
- Look at the listing. Most show last year's taxes.
- Look it up yourself. The city or county treasurer's website lets you search by address or tax key number.
- Ask your lender to build the payment with the real tax number, not an estimate from a website. I work with several trusted loan officers, and they do this every day.
What this means when you're choosing
A lower price with higher taxes can cost more each month than a higher price with lower taxes. So compare the full monthly payment, not just the price. That's the number you'll live with.
If you want to talk it through
If you're in Franklin or nearby and want to compare the monthly cost of two homes, call me. I'm a local Realtor in Franklin, WI, with Realty Experts LLC, and I answer the phone. I'll pull the tax bills. No pressure.
See how I help buyers in Franklin. I'm Rich Barnes, a Franklin WI Realtor, and my number is 414-899-8146.